Group Video Project
- Can AI Replace Tutors? -- General Audience. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jx7sTidBF9w
- Can AI Replace Tutors? -- Professional Audience. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMS4kjELDWg
Video Peer-Review -- General Audience:
Review: The topic was covered well, and briefly touched on some of the issues behind autonomous weapons and human intervention. The quality of the video was well put together with video clips for visuals and informative text. Overall, very engaging and carries the viewer along with cute and light music. I'm not entirely sure I would know, if I weren't an active student who understood this was a group assignment, that it was a joint team effort until the end, when "Group 8" was displayed, suggesting that the video likely was made by a group. Some of the information uses advanced vocabulary, which may be familiar to some viewers in the general audience, but not all.
Suggestion: I recommend using a voice-over, if no changes are wanted to be made to the video, to build on some of the information given in text for users unfamiliar with the mentioned concepts or terminology. If there is a desire to avoid voice-overs altogether, the text could include a follow-up explanation or expansion on some of the points made, such as "Categorical ban or regulatory approach" is not middle-school friendly in that they won't understand what the presenter means by "Categorical ban" or what would be considered "regulatory approach."
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Review: The topic of delivery drones was beautifully presented with high quality audio and spokesmanship (though, now that I've discovered AI is being used for voiceovers, if this is not the natural speaker, the following review holds true). Absolutely loved this presentation! It presented a very clear objective and gave appropriate detail with engaging video clips that aligned well with the speech. Very approriate for the general audience. Introduces the group at the beginning of slides, indicating a joint effort.
Review: Well structured, clear agenda and objective. Voice over is slightly theatrical, which contributes to the intensity of the topic itself. Vocabulary is advanced and certainly meets professional standards, with ample information build upon the texts within the presentation. Authors team members to illustrate team effort, and uses supportive visual aids that engages with the view. I love this presentation, but I have been battling its approriateness for professionals, as it still appears somewhat geared toward the general audience in style, but professional in context.
Reflection
This week challenged us to meet multiple deadlines throughout the project and I was fortunate to be introduces to productivity tools that my teammates have used to support the development of our project. Everyone pulled through temendously and the entire final piece came together smoothly. I don't think I'll be using Canva for power point editing, however. We did utilize this platform and were pleasantly surprised by a lot of its features. Some areas in Canva could benefit from some additional features that other editors offer, however, the real issue lies in its bugginess. The interactions are inconsistent between the members working on that particular piece, more so within the editing features. This was a learning experience for all of us, but even with this set back, we were able to pull together to resolve the matter.